September 2003


FEATURE STORY

Insights into the latest wireless LAN security issues

War Drive of Atlanta, Chicago & San Francisco:
57 % of Enterprise Wireless LANs Not Encrypted

Despite screaming headlines of major security risks, many enterprises are still incredibly vulnerable to rogue wireless LANs and insecure WLAN access points.

More than half of all access points still do not encrypt their traffic and 9 percent of all access points were determined to be unauthorized "rogues," according to a recent study of wireless LANs in the business districts of Atlanta, Chicago and San Francisco.

Last month, AirDefense engineers conducted a war drive in the three cities. The results indicate that many enterprises are at risk of unsanctioned access points and are ignoring the need for the most basic form of security - encryption.


Compiled Stats of Atlanta, Chicago & San Francisco
  Total Access Points Detected 1,136
  Access Points without Encryption 650 (57 %)
  Rogue APs (100 % default settings) 104 (9 %)
  Access Points Broadcasting SSID 876 (77 %)
  Consumer-Grade Access Points 331 (29 %)
  Ad Hoc Networks 45 (32 unencrypted)


The surveys were conducted by
driving the streets around office buildings. For Atlanta, the war drive was conducted on a 10-mile stretch of Peachtree Street from Buckhead to downtown. The Chicago and San Francisco war drives were conducted in the downtown areas and financial districts of both cities.

Of the 1,136 access points detected in the three cities, 650 - 57 percent - did not utilize any form of encryption, such as WEP, WPA, LEAP, PEAP or other proprietary solutions. AirDefense determined that 104 access points - 9 percent of the total - were rogue access points because they were in complete default settings for their SSID, channel, IP addressing and broadcasting of their SSIDs.

The war drive DID NOT check these access points for default passwords. In fact, the engineers conducting the war drive made special effort to make sure that they never connected to any of the wireless LANs that were detected.

War Drive Stats for Each City
    Atlanta Chicago San Francisco
  Total Access Points 444 235 457
Access Points without Encryption 277 135 238
  Rogue APs (100 % default settings) 36 25 43
Access Points Broadcasting SSID 393 158 328
  Consumer-Grade Access Points 169 39 123
Percentage of Total Traffic Encrypted 8% 78% 91%
  Unencrypted Ad Hoc Networks 3 8 21


The total number of rogue wireless LANs could potentially be much higher than the reported 9 percent; 331 access points - 29 percent - were determined to be consumer-grade products from vendors, such as Linksys, D-Link and Netgear. Larger enterprises are not likely to deploy access points from these vendors.

Insecure ad hoc networks were another issue identified in the survey across the three cities. The war drive identified 45 of these peer-to-peer networks; 32 of the ad hoc networks were not encrypted.

While the majority of access points in each city did not use encryption, the actual traffic observed varied from city to city. It seems as if the most active enterprise wireless LANs in San Francisco and Chicago did use some form of encryption. Of the total traffic observed in San Francisco, 91 percent was encrypted. In Chicago, 78 percent of the observed traffic was encrypted. However, the war drive in Atlanta showed that only 8 percent of the total traffic was encrypted.

 Knowledge Center
 AirDefense is your source for the latest information about WLAN security